No More ROTC at HC?

Published by

on

Joshua Rosenberg ‘29

A few weeks ago, an article by a fellow College of the Holy Cross student caught my eye. Entitled “No More ROTC at HC”, the article suggests that the College should not have a Reserve Officers’ Training Corps (ROTC) contingent on campus. For those unaware, ROTC is a dual curriculum program in which students receive financial assistance to attend college, while also being trained to take on an officer position in the American Armed Forces after graduation.

The aforementioned article suggests that ROTC exploits low-income and minority teenagers by offering free college in exchange for them joining a reprehensible and corrupt institution, and that the values of the College do not agree with ROTC or military service as a whole. I do not agree with this analysis. Is it true that ROTC as a national institution attracts people from under-represented communities by offering them financial assistance to attend college? Of course, but it is not as if certain segments of the population are being forcibly conscripted into ROTC. Without this financial assistance, people from these very communities would not have access to a world-class education such as is offered at Holy Cross. Beyond that, ROTC students do not have to commit themselves to military service until their junior year, at which point they sign up for a set amount of time in service. (Of course, it is important to note that not signing a contract may mean that a student has to repay the financial assistance they received.)

I am not in ROTC myself, nor do I disagree that the U.S. military has undertaken certain unfortunate actions since its conception, nor that it is the right of all Americans to criticize the military and government as a whole. However, I do disagree with the statements that military service is irrespectable or that Americans should be ashamed to take advantage of military service in order to achieve upward social mobility.

I spoke to a fellow student in Naval ROTC, who on the condition of anonymity, agreed to provide me with a comment: “The point of the program is simply to allow students to commission as naval officers upon graduation. People’s drive to do this is rooted in values that promote humility in themselves to serve the greater Western values that allow an institution like Holy Cross to exist, against those in the world who have no greater pleasure in attempting to destroy them with radical ideology. This is rooted entirely in Catholic teaching of just war theory rooted in Aquinas and Augustine. As a matter of fact, one of our graduates, Fr. Joseph T. O’Callahan SJ, was the first Navy chaplain awarded the Medal of Honor for his heroic life-saving conduct during WW2.”

It would seem that many people find no incongruence between Holy Cross’ values and the institution of ROTC. Ultimately, the presence of ROTC at Holy Cross need not represent a rejection of the College’s Jesuit, Catholic values, but rather an opportunity for students to put those values into practice through service, discipline, and sacrifice. While reasonable people may disagree about the actions of the American military, that disagreement should not diminish the dignity of those who choose to serve. Rather than calling for ROTC’s removal, we should recognize that there is room at Holy Cross for students who seek to serve their country just as there is room for those who choose a different path.

5 responses to “No More ROTC at HC?”

  1.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    L

  2. Scott Schaeffer-Duffy '80 Avatar
    Scott Schaeffer-Duffy ’80

    The author says the US military has taken “certain unfortunate actions since its conception.” Actually, the US military killed between 1.3 and 3.8 million people, most of them civilians, in Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos; 109,032 in Iraq, 66,081 of whom civilians; 176,000 in Afghanistan, 70,000 of whom civilians. This carnage represents more than “unfortunate actions.” Pope Francis and Pope Leo have made it clear that modern warfare is so catastrophically lethal for civilians that it can no longer ever be just. Participation in ROTC has no place on a Catholic campus.

  3.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Please explain why the Rougeau article published earlier has been scrubbed.

  4. T Avatar
    T

    “Without this financial assistance, people from these very communities would not have access to a world-class education… Beyond that, ROTC students do not have to commit themselves to military service until their junior year…” hey so this is what we call ‘enlist or you dont graduate let alone go to college’, which is by definition coercion. Hope this helps ❤️

    1.  Avatar
      Anonymous

      Hi! People of low-income can go to Holy Cross without joining ROTC. ROTC is not the sole path for low-income students to afford attending the College. There are plenty of financial aid options at Holy Cross, and you can most definitely go to school if you are a low-income student. If you speak to the ROTC students, most join the program because they believe in the mission. The assumption that student participation in ROTC is purely due to financial coercion overlooks the voluntary nature of the program and the students’ dedication to its mission.

Leave a Reply