Gianna Micieli ‘30
Staff Writer
The Unsettling Hospitality faculty group, consisting of Professors Isabelle Jenkins, Timothy Joseph, Frances Maughan-Brown, Christopher Staysniak, and Hayley Stefan, joined efforts with the SPEECH peer educators in hosting a dialogue dinner event on Tuesday, Nov. 10. The event explored what it means to be hospitable and welcoming on the Holy Cross campus to our Worcester neighbors and surrounding communities.
The event surrounded the concept of the “Private Property. No Trespassing” signs that have been posted around campus buildings. The posters for the Dialogue Dinner event depict these “Private Property” signs housed on a tent. This tent carries a deeper meaning. As the Unsettling Hospitality faculty group shares, the tent, similar to the one that they had at one of their group events in 2025, is “symbolically important as a place to gather, a porous, temporary shelter, that allows a community to form without settling, a little like a college campus”.
This symbolism of the tent felt reflective of the concept of a dialogue dinner at its core, as an unexpected community was built in an unexpected place. One of the best ways to be truly hospitable, as I have learned throughout my Montserrat course (which is also called “Unsettling Hospitality” and is taught by one of the five faculty, Professor Maughan-Brown), is to allow oneself to be open to others, receiving and sharing a multitude of opinions and beliefs. We are all members of one community – the Holy Cross community – and even though many of my fellow table mates came from very different backgrounds, the word that we decided best described our evening together was “connected”. The dialogue dinner system encourages all of its members to share what is on their minds, whether it is a new and developed thought, or whether it is something that they have been pondering and researching throughout their entire lives. This system is encouraging and affirming of the basics of being hospitable, while also allowing its members to build their own perspectives.
As for the future of Unsetting Hospitality at Holy Cross, the faculty group shared with me that they hope that their effort might disrupt or interrupt “our common understanding of hospitality,” so that as a community, we can develop a more “rigorous hospitality,” or “an opening that exposes us to the life-giving care-taking demands of the other.” Their collaboration with SPEECH makes sense in this context, as participating in a dialogue dinner, as I observed, allowed me and my peers to open ourselves up to not only the other people at our table, but to our community and other communities as a whole. Even by going through the dialogue dinner ground rules, such as respecting other opinions and every member getting a chance to share what they believe, it felt as though the hopes and desires of the Unsettling Hospitality group were being exercised and appreciated.
In addition to potential continued programming, the Unsettling Hospitality faculty group is currently putting together a volume of scholarly essays, which they hope will open “new paths for teaching, research and engaging in our communities.”
Being hospitable, and the question of what rigorous hospitality requires, correlates with Holy Cross’ mission. One part in particular that the faculty group points out is being attentive to “our special responsibility to the world’s poor and powerless”. While many Holy Cross students are welcomed into parts of the Worcester community, whether that be for events or for Community-Based Learning experiences, as was brought up in my own dialogue dinner conversations, a dichotomy exists within the hospitality that the Holy Cross community itself offers.
As the Unsettling Hospitality group further points out, “each time we use the figural term “open,” an unsettling hospitality is invoked”; as I have encountered in my Montserrat studies, there can be conditions applied to hospitality, making it obsolete and oftentimes unsettling. Part of their efforts, as the faculty group shared with me, is that the unsettling hospitality that surrounds us “becomes more noticeable on our campus, and that our campus opens in response to it”.
In all, we are one community, built on the idea of cura personalis, but does, or should, “care for the whole person” also include care of others? As brought to my attention by the incredible faculty group, students and other faculty should feel impassioned to join or support these efforts because “we belong to each other” (Mother Teresa).
There are countless ways, big and small, that students can get involved with Unsettling Hospitality, whether that is participating in a Social Action and Civic Leadership certificate, learning about CIS concentrations, doing a neighborhood clean-up with GCR, joining Pax Christi, or simply just noticing and having conversations, like dialogue dinners! Hospitality truly is all around us, and as we enter into the season of thanks and gratitude, try to engage in a hospitable practice of your choosing!

Leave a Reply