Joshua Rosenberg ‘29
Staff Writer
Privately operated prisons have been in the news quite a lot as of late, mainly for their role in housing (and reportedly abusing) those arrested by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). This article will not touch on whether or not certain people held in privately operated prisons deserve to be imprisoned, but will instead argue that the private prison industry should not exist at all.
A product of Reagan-era privatization (but having previous historical precedent), private prisons are prisons operated by corporations which the government pays to take and hold prisoners. Since they are for-profit, these prisons should operate more efficiently and more cheaply than a prison run by the government, or so the argument goes. Currently, around eight percent of American prisoners are held in private prisons, which equals a little over 90,000 people. It is also worth noting that an estimated 79 percent of the immigrant detention population is held in private prisons, with the two largest corporations being the GEO Group and CoreCivic.
Since private prisons are for-profit, they have an incentive to cut corners wherever possible in order to maximize revenue, even when that means disrespecting the humanity of those they are being paid to contain. While criminals deserve to be in prison, they are still people and deserve, at the very least, adequate access to food, water and healthcare. Remember that the Constitution guarantees against cruel and unusual punishment; to act otherwise is contrary to the civilized ideas of our society.
For example, take the GEO Group’s Adelanto ICE Processing Facility of California, which has seen at least five detainee deaths in recent times. One former detainee, Marco Jose Topete, claimed that prison staff failed to clean and change his bandages for six days. Whether this is due to malice, a lack of staff at the facility, or some combination of both, we may never know. However, one thing is clear: a focus on profit maximization means private prison companies employ as few people as possible and cut as many corners as possible. According to former CoreCivic employee Bill Rogers, the focus on employing as few people as possible leads to unsafe conditions for both prisoners and staff. While it would be naïve to suggest that government-run prisons have no issues, increased transparency makes it easier for those issues to be corrected,
Opposition to private prisons is also rooted in deeper, more philosophical rationale: only the state, (ideally) as representative of the people, should have the right to rehabilitate, and yes, punish, criminals. From a certain point of view, the confinement of criminals and the protection of the public from dangerous elements can be seen as an almost sacred duty that is undertaken by the state to allow for the better functioning of society. This sacred duty should not be defiled by those who are less interested in protecting society than they are interested in maximizing how much taxpayer money they can pocket. If the state really is the only party with a monopoly on violence, the state should also be the only party with a monopoly on confinement and punishment.
It is also to be noted that private prison corporations have an alleged habit of donating to politicians that support their continued operation. Would it be out of line to ask whether or not the politicians receiving these donations have an incentive to advocate for policies that go beyond the tenet of law and order, and that instead push for more incarceration as a way for their donors to profit?
With these facts in mind, and between their alleged abuses of people and of taxpayer money, their injection of corporate money into the political sphere and their defiling of the state’s responsibility to manage anti-social elements, it is clear that private prison companies have no place in the present or future of our nation.

Leave a Reply